Saturday, May 9, 2009

Do orthotics help back pain?


Is there evidence that foot orthotics help back pain? According to this review, NO.

The conclusion of an analysis of the available research on the use of foot insoles in treating or preventing back pain is this, “There is strong evidence that insoles are not effective for the prevention of back pain. The current evidence on insoles as treatment for low back pain does not allow any conclusions.”

The abstract for this analysis may found at:

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2009/04200/Insoles_for_Prevention_and_Treatment_of_Back_Pain_.11.aspx

It should be noted that this review of the research relates to back pain, not disc herniations

Prolotherapy (aka sclerotherapy) Treatment for Back and Disc Pain

What is prolotherapy?

Prolotherapy is the injection of an irritating substance, usually glucose, into ligaments to cause scarring (hence the name sclerotherapy) and thickening of the ligaments. This is believed to increase the ligamentous stability of joints and reduce the symptoms. While there are plenty of testimonials and anecdotal evidence (like so many back care treatments), the scientific evidence is mixed and for the most part inconclusive. The doctors who provide prolotherapy cite selective studies (purposely leaving out less complementary studies) and use testimonials to sell this procedure.

In the May 1, 2009 edition of the prestigious journal Spine, a review of evidence of the various non-surgical spine interventions came to this conclusion:

“We found good or fair evidence that prolotherapy, facet joint injection, intradiscal steroid injection, and percutaneous intradiscal radiofrequency thermocoagulation are not effective.” *

Prolotherapy usually includes a program of exercise, vitamins, and ergonomics, so some skeptics of this procedure believe that the results may be attributed to a combination of lifestyle changes and placebo. Though this treatment is mainly performed by osteopathic and medical physicians, it is considered an alternative medicine therapy.

Here is a partial list of journal abstracts relating to prolotherapy:

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2004/01010/Prolotherapy_Injections,_Saline_Injections,_and.4.aspx

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2009/05010/Nonsurgical_Interventional_Therapies_for_Low_Back.15.aspx

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15106234


*Spine:

1 May 2009 - Volume 34 - Issue 10 - pp 1078-1093

doi: 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181a103b1

Literature Review

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Hierarchy of Treatment for Lumbar Disc Herniations

In the case of weakness, altered bladder or bowel function or true numbness surgery may be your best option. But in the case of non-surgical disc herniations there are several options for treatment. These options range from watchful waiting (doing nothing and hope that you get better), to exercise, drugs, physical and massage therapy, chiropractic, spinal injections, acupuncture, and finally surgery. Since there is not a clear evidence-based algorithm for lumbar disc herniations it is best to start with the safest treatment and only progress to more dangerous treatments if the safe treatment fails.
This pyramid denotes the hierarchy of treatments from the least invasive to the most invasive, which also mirrors the safest to the most dangerous. I should note that drugs do not increase the likelihood of aggravating a herniated disc or herniating a disc. Their risk is the potential damage of organs and systems.

©
Other disc herniation guidelines are frequently based on consensus rather than on empirical evidence. What that means is that a group of "subject matter experts" are asked their opinion. Then they compile these opinions together and create a algorithm of care or guideline. Unfortunately consensus projects are usually steeped in professional bias. Surgeons will recommend surgery sooner, anesthesiologists will liberally recommend epidural spinal injections, therapists will recommend therapy, athletic trainers will recommend exercise, and so forth. If we remove professional bias we find that there is not much evidence for one treatment over another. That leaves us with safety as our guiding light in determining which treatment to utilize.

Hierarchy of treatment from least dangerous to most dangerous:

1. Relative Rest, Behavior Modification, Ergonomic Training, Watchful Waiting

2. Chiropractic Care, Physiotherapy Modalities, & Extension Exercises

3. Stabilization Exercises (Increases disc pressure and has the potential to provoke disc injuries)

4. Analgesics and Muscle Relaxants (Higher risk is due to systemic effects, not increased risk of disc injury.)

5. Pain Clinic Interventions (Including epidural injections and other “needle interventions”)

6. Surgery

The Epidemic of Disc Derangements

Modern society has an epidemic of disc derangements. These derangements have many names: herniations, protrusions, extrusions, bulges, tears and discititis. This epidemic is the result of many facets of modern living. The way we sit, the way we drive, the way we work, the way we play are all contributing factors. Our sedentary life, long commutes, and prolonged sitting in front of a computer all add to back pain and specifically to disc derangements.

The advent of MRIs and CTs have made the diagnosis of a disc injury easier. Ironically, it is now too easy to diagnose a disc injury. For example, one study showed that over 50% of the people who had never had spinal trouble had bulging or herniated discs visible on MRI. In fact only 36 % had normal discs. This points to the probability that many disc derangements are coincidental findings and not the main source of symptoms.

MRI studies show abnormal discs in virtually everyone, whether they have symptoms or not. This has led to more invasive treatment of spinal symptoms that was present prior to the advent of advanced diagnostics like the MRI.

This blog will attempt to protect the reader through education in evidence-based self-care.














A Word of Warning

Certain spinal symptoms require an immediate surgical consultation: Loss of bowel or bladder control, urinary retention, neurological sexual dysfunction, muscle weakness or flaccidity, neurological deficit, numbness of the genitalia, or numbness in the distribution of a saddle. See your physician immediately if you have any of these symptoms or the red flags posted below.

Red Flags for Potentially Dangerous Conditions

These conditions need immediate medical attention

Conditions

Red Flags

Spinal Fractures

  • Trauma (falling, car accident…)
  • Osteoporosis: Even minor trauma can cause fractures in people who have osteoporosis. Risk for osteoporosis increases with age or with the use of steroids or transplant suppression drugs.

Infection or Tumor

  • Pain that is worse at night
  • The use of Corticosteroids or HIV or immune suppressive drugs (drugs that reduce symptoms that help fight disease)
  • Unexplained weight loss
  • Night sweats, chills, fever
  • History of cancer
  • Recent infection

Severe Neurological Conditions

  • Bladder or bowel dysfunction
  • Numbness of the anus or genitals
  • Weakness of the legs
  • Numbness in the distribution of [both] your inner thighs



No blog is a replacement for a competent doctor. This blog is not intended to be a substitute for the advice of your doctor, but rather a supplement to your patient-doctor relationship. This blog is not intended to provide self-diagnosis and treatment of herniated discs.

The risks of self-care include delaying timely and appropriate professional care and possible risk of permanent impairment.

Copyright © 2009