Showing posts with label herniation treatments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label herniation treatments. Show all posts

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Hierarchy of Treatment for Lumbar Disc Herniations

In the case of weakness, altered bladder or bowel function or true numbness surgery may be your best option. But in the case of non-surgical disc herniations there are several options for treatment. These options range from watchful waiting (doing nothing and hope that you get better), to exercise, drugs, physical and massage therapy, chiropractic, spinal injections, acupuncture, and finally surgery. Since there is not a clear evidence-based algorithm for lumbar disc herniations it is best to start with the safest treatment and only progress to more dangerous treatments if the safe treatment fails.
This pyramid denotes the hierarchy of treatments from the least invasive to the most invasive, which also mirrors the safest to the most dangerous. I should note that drugs do not increase the likelihood of aggravating a herniated disc or herniating a disc. Their risk is the potential damage of organs and systems.

©
Other disc herniation guidelines are frequently based on consensus rather than on empirical evidence. What that means is that a group of "subject matter experts" are asked their opinion. Then they compile these opinions together and create a algorithm of care or guideline. Unfortunately consensus projects are usually steeped in professional bias. Surgeons will recommend surgery sooner, anesthesiologists will liberally recommend epidural spinal injections, therapists will recommend therapy, athletic trainers will recommend exercise, and so forth. If we remove professional bias we find that there is not much evidence for one treatment over another. That leaves us with safety as our guiding light in determining which treatment to utilize.

Hierarchy of treatment from least dangerous to most dangerous:

1. Relative Rest, Behavior Modification, Ergonomic Training, Watchful Waiting

2. Chiropractic Care, Physiotherapy Modalities, & Extension Exercises

3. Stabilization Exercises (Increases disc pressure and has the potential to provoke disc injuries)

4. Analgesics and Muscle Relaxants (Higher risk is due to systemic effects, not increased risk of disc injury.)

5. Pain Clinic Interventions (Including epidural injections and other “needle interventions”)

6. Surgery