Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Protecting the Lumbar Disc in Squatting Motions

Cross-Fitness Injury Prevention: Protecting the Lumbar Disc in Squatting Motions

By William E. Morgan & Chris Feil

Editor's note: This is the second in a continuing series on cross-fitness training. The first article appeared in the Sept. 9 issue.
With the rising number of people joining the cross-fitness movement and the lack of adequately trained coaches, there is a high likelihood that we will continue to experience an increase in cross-fitness-related injuries.

While the cross-fitness movement has many positive benefits and we do not want to discourage people from exercising, we need to be able to protect those interested in this increasingly popular exercise program. Cross-fitness, as stated in our previous article, is based largely on the implementation of compound motion patterns that use groups of muscles, rather than isolated muscles. The workouts are varied and seek to maintain physiological confusion and turbulence to continually challenge participants' bodies to adapt to higher levels of fitness. A mainstay of these programs is squatting motions.
Our first article provided an overview of this fitness phenomenon. Now let's discuss some specific biomechanical considerations of the exercises commonly performed in cross-fitness training, with specific emphasis on the principles of protecting the lumbar disc while squatting.
Perfect Practice Makes Perfect; Practice Just Makes Permanent
Squatting is required to perform dozens of exercise variations used in cross-fitness programs: squats, dead-lifting, power cleans, clean and jerks, truck tire flipping, kettlebell presses, bends and thrusts (aka, burpies), lunge walking, box jumping, jumping lunge squats and more. These exercises are frequently performed rapidly while striving to execute a high number of repetitions as part of a timed workout. Exercising in this manner quickly fatigues the participants, increasing the likelihood of form degradation. This is usually manifested in flexion of the lumbar spine.
We know from Alf Nachemson's work1 that curling the lumbar spine forward increases disc pressure, especially when lifting. We also know that lumbar flexion encourages migration of the nucleus pulposa posterior toward the spinal nerves (Figure 1). Maintenance of normal lumbar lordosis is protective for preventing disc injuries (Figure 2).


image
Figure 1 (left): This lifter curls their spine forward. This method of lifting causes the nucleus of the disc to migrate posterior, increasing the likelihood of a lumbar disc derangement. This method of lifting is dangerous and should be avoided. Figure 2 (right): Maintenance of a normal lumbar lordosis when squatting is protective for preventing disc injuries. Note that this lifter bends forward pivoting only at the hips, not the spine. In this manner, forward truncal fl exion can safely take place and lumbar disc injury is avoided.   It is important to maintain the lumber spine in lordosis whenever squatting or bending. The lower you bend, the more likely you are to flex the spine. The more you flex your spine, the more likely you are to sustain a disc injury. Truck tire flipping and sandbag lifting, both of which are popular cross-fitness exercises, require squatting deep enough to allow the back of your hand to reach the ground prior to lifting. This is more dangerous than dead-lifting a barbell that is 10-12 inches above the floor. Rapid tire flipping while competing against a stopwatch further increases the likelihood of injury.
Proper squatting technique will reduce the likelihood of spine injury. The primary components of a proper squat include: maintaining lumbar lordosis, proper hip motion, gluteal activation, and core stiffening. These are all integral parts of the squatting motion and are difficult to tease out into individual components. For the sake of clarity, we will address each component in separate articles while alluding to the other components.
It is our contention that before anyone begins a cross-fitness program, they should know how to perform a proper squatting motion, and have practiced it enough times to establish an enduring neurological "groove" - a neurological motor pattern that has been practiced to the point of becoming the dominant sequence of motion for a particular action. In regards to neurologic motor patterns, practice does not make perfect. Perfect practice makes perfect. Practice just makes permanent.
Cross-fitness aspirants should practice proper squatting to the point that they virtually cannot squat wrong. Only after a safe squatting groove is established should a participant progress to more advanced programs.
The Proper Squat
Begin by locking the lumbar spine into natural lordosis while standing with your feet slightly wider than shoulder-width apart and your toes turned out slightly. The chest should be held out and the abdominal muscles stiffened. Continue to hold the lumbar spine in a stiff lordosis and use the movement of your hips to lower your body. Your buttocks should travel inferior and posterior as you squat.
It cannot be emphasized enough that hip motion is more important than spine motion when it comes to protecting the lumbar spine. Virtually all lumbopelvic motion of squatting should come from the hips. As you descend and ascend during the squat, attempt to engage your gluteal muscles by maintaining a constant low-level contraction of external rotation of the hips. (We will discuss gluteal activation more fully in a subsequent article.)
An effective method to enforce proper squatting technique is the use of a rod held against the spine as a proprioceptive feedback tool (Figure 3). If the subject varies from proper technique, they will feel their back change positions in relation to the rod. When done correctly, the spine will maintain the same contact with the rod throughout the entire squatting motion and the hips will do virtually all of the movement.
In addition to proper technique, it is important to identify the most hazardous time of day to challenge the lumbar discs. Due to the diurnal effects of disc hydration, discs hydrate at night and lose hydration throughout the weight-bearing hours of the day; discs are larger and more prone to injury in the early morning. For this reason, we recommend that strenuous activities such as rigorous squatting exercises be avoided for the first 1 1/2 hours after rising.
Componets of Proper Squatting
Stiffening of the core muscles
Maintain a lumbar lordosis
Use your hips, not your spine
Gluteal activation
Whether you are an 85-year-old woman with osteoporosis or the most avid cross-fitness devotee, proper squatting technique is important.  Learning how to squat safely should be part of virtually every patient's program of spinal hygiene. Squatting is not just an exercise; it is an integral part of human existence and is important for independent living. (One of the factors that will compel the elderly or infirmed to relocate into an assisted living community is the inability to squat onto a commode or to rise from it.) Aside from helping cross-fitness enthusiasts, your increased knowledge of the technicalities of squatting motions should help virtually all of your patients enjoy healthier and more fulfilling lives.
Reference
  1. Nachemson AL. In vivo discometry in lumbar discs with irregular nucleograms. Acta Orthop Scand, 1965;36;426.

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Navy, Department of Defense or the U.S. government. This is the second in a series of articles addressing cross-fitness. Future articles will present foundational components of core stabilization and gluteal activation, as well as the prevention of shoulder injuries.  This article was originally posted in the pages of Dynamic Chiropractic and is subject to their copyright  restrictions.


Dr. William Morgan, who served in Naval and Marine Corps Special Warfare units, is credentialed at Bethesda's National Naval Medical Center and Walter Reed Army Medical Center. He serves as a chiropractic consultant to various U.S. government executive health clinics in Washington, D.C., and is the team chiropractor for the U.S. Naval Academy's football team.

Core Stiffness and Cross Fitness

Core Stiffness and Cross Fitness

Without the Stiffness There Is No Fitness


By William E. Morgan & Chris Feil

Editor's note: This is the third in a continuing series on cross-fitness training. The first article appeared in the Sept. 9 issue; the second in the Oct. 7 issue of DC.

The rising tide of cross-fitness popularity, for all of its potential fitness benefits, has the potential to cause a tsunami of lumbar spine injures if improperly implemented. In this third installment in our series on cross-fitness, let's discuss the importance of core muscle activation during cross-fitness exercise. Much has been written about the role of the core muscles in protecting the spine from injury in recent years, but this information is taking too long to trickle down to the gyms and cross-fitness clubs around the world. Properly engaging the core can enhance athleticism and reduce the risk of injury when performing rigorous exercise.

The Core

Muscle Direction Figure 1: The posterior/superficial fibers of the thoracolumbar fascia angle up and away from the spine. Though these fibers are continuous with the latisimus dorsi, they are connected to the transverse abdominis (TrA) through the lateral raphe (based on Bogduk11). The term core is bantered about in all corners of the health and fitness industry, yet to most people who use this word it remains a vague, almost nebulous description of supportive stomach and back muscles. We would like to solidify the term and provide a workable definition of the core, at least as we currently understand the term: The core muscles are the truncal muscles that support and stabilize the torso, protect the spine, and allow power transfer through the torso.

The core includes global stabilization muscles such as the transverse abdominis (TrA), the internal oblique (IO), and external oblique (EO); and intersegmental stabilizers such as the multifidus muscles.1 Since the list of muscles composing the core is a moving target depending on authorship, we would rather concentrate on core function than try to generate a composite list of the core muscles. However, certain muscles are central to any discussion of the core: the TrA, OI, OE, multifidus, rectus abdominis (RA), quadratus lumborum (QL), and the muscles of the erector spinae. Some would add the iliopsoas, latisimus dorsi, gluteal muscles, hip adductors, and hamstrings to this list.

The individual muscles of the core are each capable of contributing to several different functions, and no function is isolated to an individual muscle. The core is a complex and integrated network of muscles that work in synchrony to support the torso with stiffness and strength. It is impractical to try to isolate the function of individual muscles such as the TrA. In fact, when the core muscles stiffen in concert, their total strength surpasses the sum of the individual muscles.

Muscle Cross Section Figure 2: The anterior/deeper fibers of the thoracolumbar fascia angle downward and away from the spine from L2- L5. They are also connected to the TrA and the internal oblique (IO) by means of the lateral raphe (based on Bogduk11). In recent years, there has been a movement afoot that promotes abdominal hollowing,1 pulling in the abdominal muscles in an attempt to isolate the TrA and indirectly activate the multifidus muscles. Stuart McGill, PhD, has found that core bracing is superior to abdominal hollowing in regards to protecting the spine from injury. Vera-Garcia (with McGill as a co-author) found that hollowing actually inhibits the multifidus' response to perturbation,2 actually reducing core stabilization.

Your Internal Weight-Lifting Belt

Weight-training belts are no longer the rage they once were and their use is ebbing in most of the realm of physical culture. This is due in part to the knowledge that weight-lifting belts are not necessary. One study revealed that the advantage in using belts may come from perceived rather than actual protection and performance enhancement.3 Belts essentially increase the amount that lifters are willing to lift. Belts interfere with the natural intrinsic stabilization of the trunk without substantial benefit and should generally be avoided.4-9

Thoracolumbar Figure 3: When the TrA and IO contract, the anterior and posterior layers of the thoracolumbar fascia are pulled taut, approximating the spinous processes [from L2-L5], and a stiffening effect takes place (based on Bogduk11). We each possess a natural, built-in weight belt that is activated by the muscles of the core. Your intrinsic stabilization corset consists of a combination of the TrA and the thoracolumbar fascia. The posterior layer of the thoracolumbar fascia angles up away from the spine (Figure 1), whereas the anterior layer of the thoracolumbar fascia angles down and away from the spine (Figure 2). They both are joined to the TrA by the lateral raphe. So, when the TrA stiffens, the contraction produces a Poisson's effect,10 which causes the spinous processes to approximate in a protective manner (Figures 3 and 4).11

A collateral benefit of TrA contraction is activation of the multifidus muscle.12 The multifidus provides intersegmental stabilization through its stiffening effect, but is difficult to contract voluntarily. Together, the global and intersegmental stabilizers protect the spine from excessive shear and torsional forces.13

Bracing the Core With Muscular Stiffness

Learning to brace the core is an important component in protecting the spine and enhancing athletic performance. While many athletes intuitively brace their core during athletic exertion, others require training. It takes only a few minutes to learn how to coax the core muscles into a protective stiffened brace, but may take months to imbed a permanent neurological groove of bracing into a particular athletic motion pattern.

Thoracolumbar Fascia Figure 4: This schematic amplifies the concept of Poisson's effect. The contraction of the transverse and oblique abdominal muscles pulls on the lateral raphe, which produces a mild approximating tension of the lumbar spinous processes. Begin in a relaxed standing posture; place the fingertips of one hand on the lumbar paraspinal muscles just to the side of the spinous processes. The other hand should be positioned on the abdominal muscles at the level of the ASIS. Bend at the waist until you feel the muscles of your lower back contract under the fingers on your back. Note how this feels and then arch your spine until the spinal muscles relax under your fingers. While maintaining this position, stiffen the abdominal muscles as if you were about to be punched in the gut. You should feel your spinal muscles contract like they did when you bent over at the waist. Note how this feels with both hands. Practice engaging these muscles until it takes little conscious effort.

If bracing in this manner aggravates a spinal condition, reduce the degree of abdominal contraction. Maximal stiffness is not required. Practice in the range of 10 percent to 25 percent of maximal stiffening. Stiffening should accompany strenuous athletic exertion. When establishing neurological groove patterns for compound motor patterns, make sure to include bracing. For squatting motions, stiffen the core throughout the entire motion, even when no weight is used.

A dilemma that often accompanies core stiffening exercises is interference with diaphragmatic breathing. When first learning to stiffen the core, consciously engage in diaphragmatic breathing until it becomes routine. Once core bracing and diaphragmatic breathing are mastered, they should be practiced or rehearsed while in exertion-induced respiratory distress until it becomes natural. Practice performing cardiovascular interval training while concentrating on core bracing and diaphragmatic breathing. In time, these two activities will be imbedded in your neurology to the point of not requiring conscious intercession.

Core Stiffness Is Fundamental to Cross Fitness

Core bracing fits into one of the creeds of the cross-fitness movement: integration of compound motion patterns rather than muscle isolation. A properly functioning and reactive core is required for high levels of athleticism whether you are an elite athlete, a cross-fitness devotee, or even an average weekend golfer. Certainly cross-fitness injuries will be curtailed if athletes maintain proper form and utilize core bracing when performing athletic activities such as squatting, tire flipping, dead-lifting, plyometric jumping drills, kettlebell drills and agility drills. If our patients are going to engage in cross-fitness programs, it is our duty to prepare them properly through treatment, prevention and education.

References

  1. Richardson C, Jull G, et al. Therapeutic Exercise for Spinal Segmental Stabilization in Low Back Pain. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, 1999:22-25.
  2. Vera-Garcia FJ, Elvira JL, Brown SH, McGill SM. Effects of abdominal stabilization maneuvers on the control of spine motion and stability against sudden trunk perturbations. J Electromyogr Kinesiol, 2006 Sep 20;17(5):556-67.
  3. McCoy MA, Congleton JJ, Johnston WL, Jiang BC. The role of lifting belts in manual lifting. Int J Ind Ergonomics, 1988;2:259-266.
  4. Majkowski GR, Jovag BW, Taylor BT, Taylor MS, Allison SC Stetts DM, Clayton RL. The effect of back belt use on isometric lifting force and fatigue of the lumbar paraspinal muscles. Spine, 1998;23(19):2104-2109.
  5. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Workplace Use of Back Belts: Review and Recommendations. Rockville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services (National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health), Publication No. 94-122, 1994.
  6. Mitchell LV, Lawler FH, Bowen D, Mote W Asundi P, Purswell J. Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of employer-issued back belts in areas of high risk for back injury. J Occup Med, 1994 Jan;36(1):90-94.
  7. Thomas JS, Lavender SA, Corcos DM, Andersson GB. Effect of lifting belts on trunk muscle activation during a suddenly applied load. Hum Factors, 1999 Dec;41(4):670-6.
  8. Reyna JR, Leggett SH, Kenny K, Holmes B, Mooney V. The effect of lumbar belts on isolated lumbar muscle strength and dynamic capacity. Spine, 1995;20(1)68-73.
  9. McGill SM, Norman RW, Sharratt MT. The effect of an abdominal belt on trunk muscle activity and intra-abdominal pressure during squat lifts. Ergonomics, 1990 Feb;33(2):147-60.
  10. See www.ecourses.ou.edu/cgi-bin/view_anime.cgi?file=m1421.swf&course=me&chap_sec=01.4
  11. Bogduk N. Clinical Anatomy of the Lumbar Spine and Sacrum, 3rd Edition. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, 2001.
  12. Hides JA, Jull GA, Richardson CA. Long-term effects of specific stabilizing exercises for first-episode low back pain. Spine, 2001;26:E243-8.
  13. Moseley GL, Hodges PW, Gandevia SC. Deep & superficial fibers of lumbar multifidus are differentially active during voluntary arm movements. Spine, 2002;27(2):E29-36.

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Navy, Department of Defense or the U.S. government. This is the third in a series of articles addressing cross-fitness. Future articles will present foundational components of core stabilization and gluteal activation, as well as the prevention of shoulder injuries. This article originally appeared in dynamic chiropractic and copyright is controlled by DC.


Dr. William Morgan, who served in Naval and Marine Corps Special Warfare units, is credentialed at Bethesda's National Naval Medical Center and Walter Reed Army Medical Center. He serves as a chiropractic consultant to various U.S. government executive health clinics in Washington, D.C., and is the team chiropractor for the U.S. Naval Academy's football team.

Saturday, May 9, 2009

Do orthotics help back pain?


Is there evidence that foot orthotics help back pain? According to this review, NO.

The conclusion of an analysis of the available research on the use of foot insoles in treating or preventing back pain is this, “There is strong evidence that insoles are not effective for the prevention of back pain. The current evidence on insoles as treatment for low back pain does not allow any conclusions.”

The abstract for this analysis may found at:

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2009/04200/Insoles_for_Prevention_and_Treatment_of_Back_Pain_.11.aspx

It should be noted that this review of the research relates to back pain, not disc herniations

Prolotherapy (aka sclerotherapy) Treatment for Back and Disc Pain

What is prolotherapy?

Prolotherapy is the injection of an irritating substance, usually glucose, into ligaments to cause scarring (hence the name sclerotherapy) and thickening of the ligaments. This is believed to increase the ligamentous stability of joints and reduce the symptoms. While there are plenty of testimonials and anecdotal evidence (like so many back care treatments), the scientific evidence is mixed and for the most part inconclusive. The doctors who provide prolotherapy cite selective studies (purposely leaving out less complementary studies) and use testimonials to sell this procedure.

In the May 1, 2009 edition of the prestigious journal Spine, a review of evidence of the various non-surgical spine interventions came to this conclusion:

“We found good or fair evidence that prolotherapy, facet joint injection, intradiscal steroid injection, and percutaneous intradiscal radiofrequency thermocoagulation are not effective.” *

Prolotherapy usually includes a program of exercise, vitamins, and ergonomics, so some skeptics of this procedure believe that the results may be attributed to a combination of lifestyle changes and placebo. Though this treatment is mainly performed by osteopathic and medical physicians, it is considered an alternative medicine therapy.

Here is a partial list of journal abstracts relating to prolotherapy:

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2004/01010/Prolotherapy_Injections,_Saline_Injections,_and.4.aspx

http://journals.lww.com/spinejournal/Abstract/2009/05010/Nonsurgical_Interventional_Therapies_for_Low_Back.15.aspx

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15106234


*Spine:

1 May 2009 - Volume 34 - Issue 10 - pp 1078-1093

doi: 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3181a103b1

Literature Review

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Hierarchy of Treatment for Lumbar Disc Herniations

In the case of weakness, altered bladder or bowel function or true numbness surgery may be your best option. But in the case of non-surgical disc herniations there are several options for treatment. These options range from watchful waiting (doing nothing and hope that you get better), to exercise, drugs, physical and massage therapy, chiropractic, spinal injections, acupuncture, and finally surgery. Since there is not a clear evidence-based algorithm for lumbar disc herniations it is best to start with the safest treatment and only progress to more dangerous treatments if the safe treatment fails.
This pyramid denotes the hierarchy of treatments from the least invasive to the most invasive, which also mirrors the safest to the most dangerous. I should note that drugs do not increase the likelihood of aggravating a herniated disc or herniating a disc. Their risk is the potential damage of organs and systems.

©
Other disc herniation guidelines are frequently based on consensus rather than on empirical evidence. What that means is that a group of "subject matter experts" are asked their opinion. Then they compile these opinions together and create a algorithm of care or guideline. Unfortunately consensus projects are usually steeped in professional bias. Surgeons will recommend surgery sooner, anesthesiologists will liberally recommend epidural spinal injections, therapists will recommend therapy, athletic trainers will recommend exercise, and so forth. If we remove professional bias we find that there is not much evidence for one treatment over another. That leaves us with safety as our guiding light in determining which treatment to utilize.

Hierarchy of treatment from least dangerous to most dangerous:

1. Relative Rest, Behavior Modification, Ergonomic Training, Watchful Waiting

2. Chiropractic Care, Physiotherapy Modalities, & Extension Exercises

3. Stabilization Exercises (Increases disc pressure and has the potential to provoke disc injuries)

4. Analgesics and Muscle Relaxants (Higher risk is due to systemic effects, not increased risk of disc injury.)

5. Pain Clinic Interventions (Including epidural injections and other “needle interventions”)

6. Surgery

The Epidemic of Disc Derangements

Modern society has an epidemic of disc derangements. These derangements have many names: herniations, protrusions, extrusions, bulges, tears and discititis. This epidemic is the result of many facets of modern living. The way we sit, the way we drive, the way we work, the way we play are all contributing factors. Our sedentary life, long commutes, and prolonged sitting in front of a computer all add to back pain and specifically to disc derangements.

The advent of MRIs and CTs have made the diagnosis of a disc injury easier. Ironically, it is now too easy to diagnose a disc injury. For example, one study showed that over 50% of the people who had never had spinal trouble had bulging or herniated discs visible on MRI. In fact only 36 % had normal discs. This points to the probability that many disc derangements are coincidental findings and not the main source of symptoms.

MRI studies show abnormal discs in virtually everyone, whether they have symptoms or not. This has led to more invasive treatment of spinal symptoms that was present prior to the advent of advanced diagnostics like the MRI.

This blog will attempt to protect the reader through education in evidence-based self-care.














A Word of Warning

Certain spinal symptoms require an immediate surgical consultation: Loss of bowel or bladder control, urinary retention, neurological sexual dysfunction, muscle weakness or flaccidity, neurological deficit, numbness of the genitalia, or numbness in the distribution of a saddle. See your physician immediately if you have any of these symptoms or the red flags posted below.

Red Flags for Potentially Dangerous Conditions

These conditions need immediate medical attention

Conditions

Red Flags

Spinal Fractures

  • Trauma (falling, car accident…)
  • Osteoporosis: Even minor trauma can cause fractures in people who have osteoporosis. Risk for osteoporosis increases with age or with the use of steroids or transplant suppression drugs.

Infection or Tumor

  • Pain that is worse at night
  • The use of Corticosteroids or HIV or immune suppressive drugs (drugs that reduce symptoms that help fight disease)
  • Unexplained weight loss
  • Night sweats, chills, fever
  • History of cancer
  • Recent infection

Severe Neurological Conditions

  • Bladder or bowel dysfunction
  • Numbness of the anus or genitals
  • Weakness of the legs
  • Numbness in the distribution of [both] your inner thighs



No blog is a replacement for a competent doctor. This blog is not intended to be a substitute for the advice of your doctor, but rather a supplement to your patient-doctor relationship. This blog is not intended to provide self-diagnosis and treatment of herniated discs.

The risks of self-care include delaying timely and appropriate professional care and possible risk of permanent impairment.

Copyright © 2009